Humanization / randomness about bschaffl HOT 6 OPEN

Amp randomization added in 09ad274.

Timing randomization added in fa25a00. With some TODOs (latency, values > 0.5).

from bschaffl.

Latency and values > 0.5 fixed too in 8a25852 and bd40abf, respectively.

from bschaffl.

I think true humanization would require groove templates: http://www.numericalsound.com/uploads/3/2/1/6/32166601/dna-groove-template-user-manual.pdf

One way would be to add support for groove templates like above, but another would be to add a sidechain midi input, whose timing information would be transfered to the main input.
Not sure if an lv2 even can have 2 midi inputs, but for now, let's assume it can, or will soon ;)

The sidechain midi would be quantized to the grid of BShaffl and the difference between the quantized and non-quantized version determines the timing of the output of Bshaffl.

You could get the sidechain midi from an audio track with a drumtrigger plugin that converts it to midi.
That way the output of BShaff gets the groove of the audio, creating something like this!

from bschaffl.

I think about an easier way. Not true "humanization". Only to "simulate" the human error rate by randomization. As many other drum machines do (including Hydrogen).

FYI, LV2 can handle multiple midi input and midi output ports. However, hosts usually have a problem with it.

Edit: But you don't need multiple MIDI ports as you have up to 16 MIDI channels.

from bschaffl.

There are several ways to humanize quantized MIDI-pattern music. You can use algorithms, a. i. (as mentioned @ linuxmusicians.com), and - of course - humans.

I can't help with a. i. as i don't have any experience. I'm very sceptic about a. i. (or a natural intelligence) can produce useful humanziation of real-time MIDI signals without pre-listening the whole track (or at least parts of it).

No doubt, you can humanize a MIDI track using human groove patterns, human MIDI sidechaining or a human-geneated MIDI track.

But we already go the algorithm way. With the amp swing, the steps swing, the amp sliders, and the str markers. By doing this you can roughly simulate a playing style. And you can spice it up with some randomness. But of course you may call it "humanized" but (you are right) it isn't human.

from bschaffl.

Agreed.
As mentioned in #12, I think we don't even need the randomness, at least when we have layers.

from bschaffl.