Hi Team,

Thanks for great work, this is not working for HDFS file system for non-secure HDFS Cluster. Below is an error:

Running on '/usr/lib'
Backing up files to '/opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup'
Running on '/var/lib'
Backing up files to '/opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup'
Run successful
Found an HDFS namenode on this host, removing JNDI from HDFS tar.gz files
Using /etc/security/keytabs/hdfs.headless.keytab to access HDFS
./hdp_support_scripts/patch_hdfs_tgz.sh: line 43: klist: command not found
Using /etc/security/keytabs/hdfs.headless.keytab to access HDFS
./hdp_support_scripts/patch_hdfs_tgz.sh: line 43: klist: command not found

We run the patch with ansible on all machines.

Added code in patch_hdfs_tgz.sh:

kinit -kt $keytab $principal # under this line.

hdfs haadmin -getAllServiceState | grep active | grep hostname
active_nn=$?
if [ $active_nn -eq 1 ]
exit 0
fi

Hello,

The script (by default) scan /opt/cloudera for jar/tar/war files. This has the affect of also modifying files which are not part of Cloudera's stack e.g. StreamSets managed by CM. Is there a way the script can check the top-level directories to ensure that they are Cloudera products before scanning?

Thanks.

IMO force-push into the main branch should not be allowed at all, for many reasons:

• for one the community/contributors here need to all the time rebase their forks, PRs, patches
• and it seems PRs got auto-closed because of this, including mine #2 :(
  (Of course in feature branches it's OK to force-push , if it helps to keep the history cleaner etc)

Also in general would be nice if Cloudera does changes via feature branches , as does the community

• and we would almost need some CI/CD incl. basic integration tests for this (with the many changes and contributions)

There is no validation on backup files.
I have a case where the backup path filled up from the script and a number of jar files didn't get backed up, but did get modified.
This means there is no rollback - very bad

if [ ! -f "$targetbackup" ]; then
  echo "Backing up to '$targetbackup'"
  cp -f "$jarfile" "$targetbackup"
fi

Hi Team,

Thanks for the great work. The readme said These defaults work for CM/CDH 6 and CDP 7. A different set of directories will be used for HDP. I'm wondering to ask does this script work on CDH5. Thanks.

If a war file contains the same file twice the script will hang when it asks for a response from the user. This becomes an issue especially when running via Ansible or other automation.

This file has this issue: /opt/cloudera/parcels/CDH-5.16.1-1.cdh5.16.1.p3368.3632/lib/hbase-solr/lib/solr-4.10.3-cdh5.16.1.war

To see the issue, run these commands:

rm -r -f /tmp/unzip_target
mkdir /tmp/unzip_target
unzip -qq /opt/cloudera/parcels/CDH-5.16.1-1.cdh5.16.1.p3368.3632/lib/hbase-solr/lib/solr-4.10.3-cdh5.16.1.war -d /tmp/unzip_target
replace /tmp/unzip_target/WEB-INF/lib/jackson-core-asl-1.8.10.jar? [y]es, [n]o, [A]ll, [N]one, [r]ename:

A proposed fix for this is to add the overwrite option -o to the unzip command. I can create a PR for this.

Some temporary directories are created but not cleaned up, causing the /tmp directories to be saturated after a while. Eg.

Please create some sort of summary.date.log file in each CDH/CDP /opt/cloudera/ scanned directory which records all of the original SHA fingerprints of the affected JAR/TAR/WAR files and the SHA fingerprints of their modified versions. This information may be helpful, but most importantly, can be used as a maker to indicate that a particular node has been secured.

Not an issue per se, just a quick sanity check if anyone would like.

[root@host]# find / -type f -name '*.jar' -exec unzip -l {} \; | grep JndiLookup.class

Issue is in cloudera-scripts-for-log4j/hdp_support_scripts/delete_jndi.sh file, where we are not passing backupdir while patching tar.gz file.

Actual code snippet with the issue:
for tarfile in $(find -L $targetdir -name "*.tar.gz" -o -name "*.tgz"); do if [ -L "$tarfile" ]; then continue fi if zgrep -q JndiLookup.class $tarfile; then $patch_tgz $tarfile fi done

Correct will be:
for tarfile in $(find -L $targetdir -name "*.tar.gz" -o -name "*.tgz"); do if [ -L "$tarfile" ]; then continue fi if zgrep -q JndiLookup.class $tarfile; then $patch_tgz $tarfile $backupdir fi done

PS: Fix of this issue was identified by my fellow colleague Davinder Singh.

I think it's more safe and proper to actually iterate the files in the JAR files instead of scanning through their binary contents:

 if unzip -l $jarfile | grep -q JndiLookup.class; then 

Should also be faster than the current implementation because the unzip utility knows how to quickly find the class names within the ZIP file dictionary without having to scan/read the entire file.

Please check each directory exists and print an info message if the directory does not exist.

I need you help because after apply patches only 2 files from Cloudera Manager can´t updated, so is necessary restores
both files (from backup"/opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup") because cloudera manager dont start again after "applied patches", restore both files then Cloudera manager start without problem.

:::Files Can´t updated (cloudera-manager-daemons):::
[0]
/opt/cloudera/cm/common_jars/log4j-1.2.17-cloudera1.9b958f437c18806864374725d91ab8b7.jar
[1]
/opt/cloudera/cm/common_jars/log4j-core-2.8.2.f3f743bada8d698e2d116e5c9951fe2f.jar

Background
Versions: CDP Private Cloud Base= 7.1.5
Cloudera Manager version= 7.2.4

output_run_log4j_patcher .log

Hi,

backups go the /tmp hardcoded.
On our systems /tmp is not big enough., so we change it to an other directory.

Question: can you make the “/tmp” backup dir an option or variable?

export TMPDIR=/opt/cloudera/tmp

changes we need to make:
local_path=“/opt/cloudera/tmp/hdfs_tar_files.${current_time}”
hdfs_bc_path=“/opt/cloudera/tmp/backup.${current_time}"

Regards, Hans

Observation from a test run of log4j patch script on HDP:

Looks like if a OS directory has symlinks to jars, its not getting followed and scanned for JndiLookup.class files.

grep: /usr/hdp/current/phoenix-server/lib/hbase-testing-util.jar: No such file or directory

Test run Log:

[root@server]# ./run_log4j_patcher.sh hdp
INFO : Running HDP/HDF patcher script: ./hdp_log4j_jndi_removal.sh '/usr/hdp/current /usr/hdf/current /usr/lib /var/lib' /opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup
INFO : Log file: output_run_log4j_patcher.hjH6lO
.
Removing JNDI from jar files
Running on '/usr/hdp/current'
Backing up files to '/opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup'
grep: /usr/hdp/current/hadoop-client/lib/ojdbc6.jar: No such file or directory
grep: /usr/hdp/current/hbase-client/lib/ojdbc6.jar: No such file or directory
grep: /usr/hdp/current/hbase-master/lib/ojdbc6.jar: No such file or directory
grep: /usr/hdp/current/hbase-regionserver/lib/ojdbc6.jar: No such file or directory
grep: /usr/hdp/current/phoenix-client/lib/hbase-testing-util.jar: No such file or directory
grep: /usr/hdp/current/phoenix-server/lib/hbase-testing-util.jar: No such file or directory
Running on '/usr/hdf/current'
Backing up files to '/opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup'
Running on '/usr/lib'
Backing up files to '/opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup'
Running on '/var/lib'
Backing up files to '/opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup'
Run successful
INFO : Finished
[root@server]#

Symlink:
[user@server]$ ll /usr/hdp/current/phoenix-client/lib/hbase-testing-util.jar
lrwxrwxrwx 1 root root 52 May 22 2018 /usr/hdp/current/phoenix-client/lib/hbase-testing-util.jar -> /usr/hdp/2.6.4.0-91/hbase/lib/hbase-testing-util.jar

Any fix for this? Or am I missing something?

There is a number of bit of code like

for jarfile in $targetdir/**/*.jar; do

Thus symlinks are being followed and bad things happen, espically with backup of the link name and not the actual file

consider using
for jarfile in $(find ${targetdir} -type f -name "*.jar") ; do

Does this script mitigate the following CVE?

• CVE-2021-45105
• CVE-2021-45046

Those CVE were found after the CVE-2021-44228 was fixed.

The Cloudera script removes the .class which is vulnerable and the previous CVE mentioned are also mitigated, can anyone confirm this?

The code here is not working (cm_cdp_cdh_log4j_jndi_removal.sh line 139)

  local backupdir=${2:-/opt/cloudera/log4shell-backup}
  mkdir -p "$backupdir/$(dirname $tarfile)"
  targetbackup="$backupdir/$tarfile.backup"
  if [ ! -f "$targetbackup" ]; then
    echo "Backing up to '$targetbackup'"
    cp -f "$tarfile" "$targetbackup"
  fi

You do a mkdir for a path and then don't use it.

I can't see any backups for the *.tar.gz in the location of the backupdir

There is something wrong with this block of code

Also the function is always creating a new tar.gz, even if there is nothing to "patch" thus touching files which don't need to be altered - this is bad.....

https://github.com/cloudera/cloudera-scripts-for-log4j/blob/main/cm_cdp_cdh_log4j_jndi_removal.sh#L63
it's missing the -name parameter after -o

line should read
for tarfile in $(find -L $targetdir -name ".tar.gz" -o -name ".tgz"); do

I fixed it locally and the find does not error any more