sverhees / master_villages Goto Github PK

Hi!

One minor correction: In Chantlisqure in Eastern Georgia, Bezhta is spoken, and not Hunzib.
Also, I could suggest adding Kistian Chechen to the Pankisi valley. They are the villages of Duisi, Dzibakhevi, Jokolo, Shua Khalatsani, Birkiani, and Omalo (not to be confused with the Omalo in Tusheti).

Thanks!
Jesse Wichers Schreur

Hi,
I have found 10 villages with two entries each in the file villages_corr.csv. In most of cases, each entry has a different value for lang (e.g. village = Akka, lang = Chechen and lang = Tabasaran), which might suggest the duplication is intentional for depicting multilingualism, but in all cases repeated villages have also different values for lat and long coordinates. If instead of using the English name village, we use the russian name rus_village, we obtain 11 villages instead (not exactly overlapping). See code and image.

villages_new <- read_tsv("data/villages_corr.csv")
which(table(villages_new$village) >1)
repeated <- subset(villages_new, village %in% c("Akka", "Beretbinə","Druzhba","Guni", "Kakamakhi", "Komsomol'skoe", "Sadovoe", "Simsir ","Siukh","Vinogradnoe", "Yuzhnoe"))
repeated

in this dataset.

• - Reproduce script for data mining (Daghestan, Chechnya, Ingushetia, Azerbaijan), retrieve:

• -- village name

• -- coordinates

• -- rayons / administrative districts

• - Annotate manual corrections in old data

• - Merge Chechnya and Ingushetia with census data

Hi!
The variable affiliation color (aff_col in villages_corr.csv) for aff = "Avar", has a value of #9900ff in most of cases, but a few of them have its value as #9494b8 . This should be unified.

Just another comment, which is not wrong, but just comes from my obsessive nature. All values for color in this variable are in their hexadecimal representation, except for that for "Georgic", which is "black". Maybe replace it for "#000000", just out of consistence? :)

I think it would be better, if we have a different versions of this dataset in order to reference to. Imagine that I've done some work with one version, then something get changed and I can't reproduce my work since then. The versions could be implemented via github releases. It is also make it possible to get a DOI via zenodo.

MIT, or GPL-2

See https://ru.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9A%D0%B0%D0%BB%D0%B0_(%D0%A0%D1%83%D1%82%D1%83%D0%BB%D1%8C%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B8%D0%B9_%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%B9%D0%BE%D0%BD)

Please edit village dialect for Verkhnee and Nizhnee Gakvari > Upper and Lower Gakvari.

Исправить высотность села Аща.
Какой у нас мастер-файл высотностей и диалектной/языковой принадлежности - туда же и кутанность указывать, и население? надо где-то онлайн все хранить

https://github.com/sverhees/master_villages/blob/master/data/villages.csv#L1964

is written Mikikh, but it is Mikik (proof).

@sverhees, have a look

I guess there are two colors for Andic languages in the villages_corr.csv:

library(tidyverse)
readr::read_tsv("https://raw.githubusercontent.com/sverhees/master_villages/master/data/villages_corr.csv") %>% 
  count(aff, aff_col)

# A tibble: 14 × 3
   aff      aff_col     n
   <chr>    <chr>   <int>
 1 Andic    #9494b8    17
 2 Andic    #9900ff    75
 3 Armenic  #fff5ee     1
 4 Avar     #009999   535
 5 Dargwa   #ff9900   292
 6 Georgic  black       2
 7 Iranian  #fffded     1
 8 Khinalug #cccc00     1
 9 Kipchak  #666666    90
10 Lak      #cc9900    74
11 Lezgic   #00cc66   304
12 Nakh     #996633   535
13 Oghuz    #cccccc    40
14 Tsezic   #ff5050    64

Please add Muslim Tat coordinates to the TALD villages dataset.

could be merged