The following files (16) have no "\version" specification and should be updated to make them consistent with other files in the archive.

BachJS/BWV997/bwv997-01prelude
BachJS/BWV997/bwv997-02fuga
BachJS/BWV997/bwv997-03sarabande
BachJS/BWV997/bwv997-04gigue
BachJS/BWV997/bwv997-05double
FrobergerJJ/Suite7/Suite7.ly
GriegE/O46/02-lamortdase
HandelGF/HWV585/sonatina-in-b-flat-major
JoplinS/a-breeze-from-alabama/a-breeze-from-alabama.ly
JoplinS/sun-flower-slow-drag/sun-flower-slow-drag.ly
RameauJP/plaintes/plaintes.ly
Traditional/Greensleaves/Greensleaves.ly

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v09/bwv-988-v09.ly

bar 16 bass odd 16th not beamed

TitelouzeJ/Ave_Maris_Stella-1er_verset/Ave_Maris_Stella-1er_verset.ly
TitelouzeJ/Ave_Maris_Stella-3e_verset/Ave_Maris_Stella-3e_verset.ly
TitelouzeJ/Ave_Maris_Stella-4e_verset/Ave_Maris_Stella-4e_verset.ly
TitelouzeJ/Pange_Lingua-2e_verset/Pange_Lingua-2e_verset.ly
TitelouzeJ/Veni_Creator-1er_verset/Veni_Creator-1er_verset.ly

Each line is a single Mutopia index but some entries are folders that may contain more than one lilypond file.

Most editors can make the conversion, but almost all of them need to updated to a more current version of lilypond anyway and running convert-ly will also make the encoding fix.

To contribute to complete this milestone, review the associated issues and assign yourself to the (unassigned) block you wish to work on. If you don't have assignment capability, add a comment to the block you will be working on.

xref: Bach Gesellschaft
(Steve Shorter)
bar 17 (second repeat), tie missing in voice 1 and 2 in treble clef (c# g)

KuhlauF/O20/sonatine-1-allegro
KuhlauF/O20/sonatine-1-andante
LullyJB/LWV71/Armide
Mendelssohn-BartholdyF/O36/paulus_3
Mendelssohn-BartholdyF/O70/elias_32
MozartWA/KV574/k574
RameauJP/sauvages/sauvages.ly
SchubertF/D118/gretchen
SchubertF/D550/forelle
SchubertF/D911/einsamkeit

Each line is a single Mutopia index but some entries are folders that may contain more than one lilypond file.

Most editors can make the conversion, but almost all of them need to updated to a more current version of lilypond anyway and running convert-ly will also make the encoding fix.

To contribute to complete this milestone, review the associated issues and assign yourself to the (unassigned) block you wish to work on. If you don't have assignment capability, add a comment to the block you will be working on.

File has no "\version" specification and should be updated to make them consistent with other files in the archive.

RameauJP/plaintes/plaintes.ly

Steve Shorter:
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v25/bwv-988-v25.ly

bar 24/25 "aes" in bass should tie

Remove text formatting as function of staff size.

File has no "\version" specification and should be updated to make them consistent with other files in the archive.

JoplinS/a-breeze-from-alabama/a-breeze-from-alabama.ly

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellchaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v14/bwv-988-v14.ly

bar 4 in treble clef, first "e" should be "f"

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v02/bwv-988-v02.ly
bar 5 first note in top voice, "b" should be "g"

File has no "\version" specification and should be updated to make them consistent with other files in the archive.

HandelGF/HWV585/sonatina-in-b-flat-major

Steve Shorter:
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v24/bwv-988-v24.ly

bar 12 "a" tie ,
bar 17 double ties(a),
bar24 double ties (bass e),
bar29 voice 2 should be d#,
b28 the first and second top voice "d"'s should not be tied

I have identified 61 Mutopia entries that have invalid unicode encodings. In the alphabetical list below, I have broken the list up into blocks of a reasonable size in the event anyone would like to participate in this update. Each line is a single Mutopia index but some entries are folders that may contain more than one lilypond file.

Most editors can make the conversion, but almost all of them need to updated to a more current version of lilypond anyway and running convert-ly will also make the encoding fix.

Block 1.
BachJS/BWV1050/brand5-3
BachJS/BWV269/bwv_269
BachJS/BWV347/bwv347
BachJS/BWV803/duetto
BachJS/BWV846/wtk1-fugue1
BachJS/BWV928/prelude_9
BachJS/O_Haupt_voll_Blut/O_Haupt_voll_Blut.ly

Block 2:
[ COMPLETE ] BeethovenLv/O62/Coriolan
BrahmsJ/O118/intermezzo
ChopinFF/O10/10-02-i
ChopinFF/O10/chopin-op-10-09-wfi
ChopinFF/O10/op-10-12-wfi
ChopinFF/O25/chopin-op-25-01
ChopinFF/O28/Chop-28-2
ChopinFF/O69/w10-h-moll-cfi
[ SKIP ] DandrieuJ/Fugue_sur_l_Ave_maris_stella/Fugue_sur_l_Ave_maris_stella.ly
GrignyNd/Grigny-Fugue_a_5/Grigny-Fugue_a_5.ly

[ COMPLETE ] Block 3.
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/01-overture
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/02-entree
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/03-gavotte
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/04-toccata
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/05-fuga
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/06-impertinence
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/07-concerto
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/08-preludio
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/09-menueti
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/10-menuetii
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/11-allegro
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/12-menuet
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/13-air
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/14-menueti
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/15-menuetii
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/16-airmitvar
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/17-allemande
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/18-passepied
[ COMPLETE ] HandelGF/Aylesford/19-menuet

Block 4.
KuhlauF/O20/sonatine-1-allegro
KuhlauF/O20/sonatine-1-andante
LullyJB/LWV71/Armide
Mendelssohn-BartholdyF/O36/paulus_3
Mendelssohn-BartholdyF/O70/elias_32
MozartWA/KV574/k574
RameauJP/sauvages/sauvages.ly
SchubertF/D118/gretchen
SchubertF/D550/forelle
SchubertF/D911/einsamkeit

Block 5.
SchulzJAP/mond/mond.ly
SchumannR/O48/Ich_grolle_nicht
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_4
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_5_1
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_5_2
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_5_3
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_6
SorF/O60/sor_op60-03
SorF/O60/sor_op60-05

Block 6.
TitelouzeJ/Ave_Maris_Stella-1er_verset/Ave_Maris_Stella-1er_verset.ly
TitelouzeJ/Ave_Maris_Stella-3e_verset/Ave_Maris_Stella-3e_verset.ly
TitelouzeJ/Ave_Maris_Stella-4e_verset/Ave_Maris_Stella-4e_verset.ly
TitelouzeJ/Pange_Lingua-2e_verset/Pange_Lingua-2e_verset.ly
TitelouzeJ/Veni_Creator-1er_verset/Veni_Creator-1er_verset.ly

Per @doughdemon: fix after Issue #9 is completed.

Cross-ref: Bach Gesellschaft
bar8, bass clef lower voice missing rest 32nd rest on beat 2, missing "g32" at the end
bar13 bass clef lower voice missing missing "f" at end of bar, extra r32
bar21 bass clef lower voice missing rest 32nd rest on beat 3, missing "e32" at the end
bar25 bass clef lower voice missing "a32 g32" at the end, extra r16 at end
bar26 bass clef lower voice missing rest 32nd rest on beat 3, missing "g32" at the end
bar27 treble clef upper voice missing rest 32nd rest on beat 3, extre r32 at the end
treble clef upper voice missing "c" on secound beat
treble clef upper voice beat 2 missing "c32"
(Steve Shorter)

BachJS/BWV1050/brand5-3
BachJS/BWV269/bwv_269
BachJS/BWV347/bwv347
BachJS/BWV803/duetto
BachJS/BWV846/wtk1-fugue1
BachJS/BWV928/prelude_9
BachJS/O_Haupt_voll_Blut/O_Haupt_voll_Blut.ly

Each line is a single Mutopia index but some entries are folders that may contain more than one lilypond file.

Most editors can make the conversion, but almost all of them need to updated to a more current version of lilypond anyway and running convert-ly will also make the encoding fix.

To contribute to complete this milestone, review the associated issues and assign yourself to the (unassigned) block you wish to work on. If you don't have assignment capability, add a comment to the block you will be working on.

bar12: bass clef "bis" should be "cis", and next "bis" should be "b" (no accidental until fixed)
bar22: lower clef, low "g" should be "b"
(Steve Shorter)

Steve Shorter:
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v27/bwv-988-v27.ly

bar 24 "gis" tie over to bar 25

File has no "\version" specification and should be updated to make them consistent with other files in the archive.

FrobergerJJ/Suite7/Suite7.ly

BrahmsJ/O118/intermezzo
ChopinFF/O10/10-02-i
ChopinFF/O10/chopin-op-10-09-wfi
ChopinFF/O10/op-10-12-wfi
ChopinFF/O25/chopin-op-25-01
ChopinFF/O28/Chop-28-2
ChopinFF/O69/w10-h-moll-cfi
GrignyNd/Grigny-Fugue_a_5/Grigny-Fugue_a_5.ly

Each line is a single Mutopia index but some entries are folders that may contain more than one lilypond file.

Most editors can make the conversion, but almost all of them need to updated to a more current version of lilypond anyway and running convert-ly will also make the encoding fix.

To contribute to complete this milestone, review the associated issues and assign yourself to the (unassigned) block you wish to work on. If you don't have assignment capability, add a comment to the block you will be working on.

Suggestion by Paul Morris

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v03/bwv-988-v03.ly

bar 5-6 middle voice "d" should be tied
bar 15-16 middle voice "a" should be tied

I have downloaded this score from IMSLP and verified this correction for this entry:

http://www.mutopiaproject.org/cgibin/piece-info.cgi?id=979

-glen

Submitted by Steve Shorter (email hidden):

Howdy!

Not sure what else to do...so I am posting this here.

There are 2 significant errors in the Goldberg Aria, which
I first identified several years ago. I did send a heads up
to the maintainer et. al. listed but there was no acknowedgment
and the error remains. The correction is simple but I don't have
a lilypond version to verify the fix. Specifically the errors are

i) Bar 18: the last eight note in the treble clef is incorrect. It
should be a "g" and not an "e". This is verified in all other
engravings and recordings.

ii) Bar 6: the dotted quarter note in the bass clef appears on beat 2.5
when it should be on beat 2. This is because of a conscious decision
to offset it to that position. In lilypond source it is offset with
"s4.",
instead of "s4" While the original score is not 100% clear, all
other engravings and recordings clearly have the dotted quarter on
beat 2 not 2.5

I appreciate that people are busy, and this error is not a
priority, but I simply want it documented.

-steve

SchulzJAP/mond/mond.ly
SchumannR/O48/Ich_grolle_nicht
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_4
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_5_1
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_5_2
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_5_3
SorF/O1/sor_op_1_6
SorF/O60/sor_op60-03
SorF/O60/sor_op60-05

Each line is a single Mutopia index but some entries are folders that may contain more than one lilypond file.

Most editors can make the conversion, but almost all of them need to updated to a more current version of lilypond anyway and running convert-ly will also make the encoding fix.

To contribute to complete this milestone, review the associated issues and assign yourself to the (unassigned) block you wish to work on. If you don't have assignment capability, add a comment to the block you will be working on.

xref: Bach Gesellschaft
(Steve Shorter)
bar8 treble clef, second voice beat 3.5 should be "g8" not "a8", rythm not correct
bar10 treble clef, top voice last note should be "fis" not "f"
bar13 treble clef, second voice first beat should be "c8. d16" not "c8 d8"
bar14 bass clef, top voice, beat 3 and 4 should be "e4 e4" not "e4 fis4"

File has no "\version" specification and should be updated to make them consistent with other files in the archive.

JoplinS/sun-flower-slow-drag/sun-flower-slow-drag.ly

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v07/bwv-988-v07.ly

bar 6 missing phrase slur
bar 14 missing phrase slur
bar 21 missing phrase slur
bar 22 missing phrase slur

File has no "\version" specification and should be updated to make them consistent with other files in the archive.

GriegE/O46/02-lamortdase

Assigned to @doughdemon

BeethovenLv/O62/Coriolan

HandelGF/Aylesford/01-overture
HandelGF/Aylesford/02-entree
HandelGF/Aylesford/03-gavotte
HandelGF/Aylesford/04-toccata
HandelGF/Aylesford/05-fuga
HandelGF/Aylesford/06-impertinence
HandelGF/Aylesford/07-concerto
HandelGF/Aylesford/08-preludio
HandelGF/Aylesford/09-menueti
HandelGF/Aylesford/10-menuetii
HandelGF/Aylesford/11-allegro
HandelGF/Aylesford/12-menuet
HandelGF/Aylesford/13-air
HandelGF/Aylesford/14-menueti
HandelGF/Aylesford/15-menuetii
HandelGF/Aylesford/16-airmitvar
HandelGF/Aylesford/17-allemande
HandelGF/Aylesford/18-passepied
HandelGF/Aylesford/19-menuet

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v10/bwv-988-v10.ly

\time should be 2/2 not 4/4
bar 11-12 third voice (is now in treble clef for 2 notes) "e2" should be tied over
bar 26-27 second voice "g" should be tied over

By Felix Janda: mutopia-check.sh

Before using it...setup the environment variable MUTOPIA_BASE (see http://www.mutopiaproject.org/UsefulScripts/readme.html) so it can find the datafiles.

Syntax:
sh composer.sh file.ly

Script reads all headers mentioned in http://www.mutopiaproject.org/contribute.html, tries to validate them and print as much useful info as possible.

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v16/bwv-988-v16.ly

\time should be 2/2 not 4/4
bar 5, treble clef, ornament is incorrect should be prallmordent not prallprall
bar 15 \turn missing
bar 18 \turn missing
bar 48 incorrect b in treble clef, should be octave lower in the bass
bar 9, bass clef, single beam through 2 beats
bar 32, treble clef, lower voice, last "g" should be "gis"
treble clef upper voice first "d" should be "e"

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v13/bwv-988-v13.ly

bar 24 treble clef, lower voice missing d#

Steve Shorter
xref: Bach Gesellschaft
http://www.mutopiaproject.org/ftp/BachJS/BWV988/bwv-988-v06/bwv-988-v06.ly

bar 10 middle voice in treble "a16" should be a8
bar 15 bass "a" should be octave lower
bar 25 bass "b" should be octave lower
bar 19 top voice "a" should be tied to the B section
bar 35 top voice "a" should be tied over to the repeat
bar 36 (last bar) top voice "g" should be octave lower