gbj / commonprayer Goto Github PK

Page:
https://www.commonprayeronline.org/en/daily-readings/2022-03-09

No psalm listed for Morning Prayer. Instead, the MP Psalm (119.49-72) is listed under the evening psalms.

Looking ahead (through 4 May / Easter 3), I notice a few things:

1. Psalm 119 gets used on Wednesdays in the Daily Office, alternating morning & evening by week.
2. Whenever the Psalm is assigned for the morning, it appears in the evening on commonprayeronline.
3. Whenever the Psalm is assigned for the evening, it is left out of commonprayeronline altogether.

https://www.commonprayeronline.org/en/daily-readings/2022-03-13

Has Ash Wed collect, but not Lent 2. Likeways for the weekdays following.

Minor issue; please let me know if reports like this are uninteresting. I'm using (and appreciating) CommonPrayer regularly, and perhaps thereby noticing random edge cases (as well as learning about both the lectionary and your design choices!).

Concerning:
https://www.commonprayeronline.org/en/readings/office/2022-03-19

The office readings for most days will list the Psalms separately, but the readings as a list of three (first, second, Gospel) for a "full" office.

For saints' days, I notice CommonPrayer keeps them separate, since there are actually two sets of two readings and they often won't mesh together well (e.g., both morning and evening will draw from different sections of the same book to tell a story).

This particular day, the Feast of St. Joseph, however, seems to do a little of both, grabbing the second reading from the evening and listing it as the first reading for BOTH morning and evening (thereby repeating it in the evening).

I automatically imported Rite I and Rite II collects from Venite, and ended up with lists of two different lengths, which suggests that some are missing from Rite II.

It would be helpful to have someone check the list of Collect IDs in those two files and see what's missing from Rite II -- and possibly even add them, if the format makes sense to you!

On Ash Wednesday, the collect displays twice:
https://www.commonprayeronline.org/en/daily-readings/2022-03-02

Feels like an off by one error.

I'll also note with amusement that I started to file an issue about the Ash Wed collect run amok! A project like this, it seems, is likely to attract "issues" that are not about your code, but about interpretation of the tradition. Case in point:

The Ash Wed collect continues throughout Lent in commonprayeronline/daily-readings. I thought this might be a bug. I see a rubric about this on BCP 217, but it seems ambiguous. Checking Hatchett, this ambiguity seems frustratingly purposeful: the 1928 BCP specified until Palm Sunday. But the earliest use of the the rubric (in 1892, following Scottish 1637) was only meant to cover the Thurs/Fri/Sat following Ash Wed. Why did the 1979 book refrain from being clear on this issue?