https://arxiv.org/pdf/2210.16771.pdf
- bitfit + ft
precision recall f1
strict
problem 0.9007 0.9076 0.9041
test 0.8944 0.8898 0.8921
treatment 0.8980 0.8933 0.8956
relax
problem 0.9562 0.9635 0.9598
test 0.9460 0.9411 0.9435
treatment 0.9526 0.9477 0.9501
overall
acc: 0.967
strict
0.8981 0.8982 0.8981
relax
0.9522 0.9523 0.9523
- bitfit reserve + ft
precision recall f1
strict
problem 0.8993 0.9166 0.9079
test 0.8989 0.8839 0.8913
treatment 0.8892 0.9037 0.8964
relax
problem 0.9524 0.9707 0.9615
test 0.9513 0.9355 0.9433
treatment 0.9398 0.9552 0.9475
overall
acc: 0.9668
strict
0.8961 0.9034 0.8997
relax
0.9483 0.9560 0.9521
- ft
precision recall f1
strict
problem 0.9098 0.9059 0.9078
test 0.8865 0.8942 0.8903
treatment 0.8990 0.8918 0.8954
relax
problem 0.9605 0.9565 0.9585
test 0.9360 0.9441 0.9401
treatment 0.9522 0.9446 0.9484
overall
acc: 0.9669
strict
0.8998 0.8983 0.8991
relax
0.9509 0.9494 0.9502
- stage ft (5 epoch bitfit then ft)
precision recall f1
strict
problem 0.8901 0.9160 0.9029
test 0.8977 0.9026 0.9002
treatment 0.8973 0.9006 0.8990
relax
problem 0.9423 0.9696 0.9558
test 0.9459 0.9511 0.9485
treatment 0.9488 0.9523 0.9505
overall
acc: 0.9669
strict
0.8944 0.9075 0.9009
relax
0.9452 0.9591 0.9521
- bitfit + ft
bitfit
precision recall f1
strict
occurrence 0.5702 0.5590 0.5646
test 0.7727 0.7890 0.7808
problem 0.7417 0.8157 0.7770
treatment 0.7750 0.8282 0.8007
clinical_dept 0.6681 0.8361 0.7427
evidential 0.8229 0.6403 0.7202
relax
occurrence 0.7151 0.7011 0.7080
test 0.8868 0.9056 0.8961
problem 0.8645 0.9508 0.9056
treatment 0.8762 0.9363 0.9053
clinical_dept 0.7358 0.9208 0.8180
evidential 0.8229 0.6403 0.7202
overall
acc: 0.8922
strict
0.7232 0.7607 0.7415
relax
0.8356 0.8789 0.8567
bitfit + ft
precision recall f1
strict
occurrence 0.6518 0.5714 0.6090
test 0.8211 0.8729 0.8462
problem 0.8465 0.8666 0.8564
treatment 0.8546 0.8653 0.8600
clinical_dept 0.7183 0.8743 0.7887
evidential 0.7187 0.7899 0.7526
relax
occurrence 0.7695 0.6747 0.7190
test 0.8921 0.9484 0.9194
problem 0.9259 0.9478 0.9367
treatment 0.9242 0.9357 0.9299
clinical_dept 0.7542 0.9180 0.8281
evidential 0.7187 0.7899 0.7526
overall
acc: 0.9136
strict
0.7989 0.8101 0.8044
relax
0.8740 0.8862 0.8801
- bitfit reserve + ft
precision recall f1
strict
occurrence 0.6719 0.5826 0.6241
test 0.8261 0.8733 0.8491
problem 0.8280 0.8823 0.8543
treatment 0.8121 0.8927 0.8505
clinical_dept 0.6341 0.9303 0.7542
evidential 0.8238 0.6756 0.7424
relax
occurrence 0.7813 0.6775 0.7257
test 0.8941 0.9452 0.9189
problem 0.9009 0.9601 0.9296
treatment 0.8697 0.9561 0.9109
clinical_dept 0.6667 0.9781 0.7929
evidential 0.8238 0.6756 0.7424
overall
acc: 0.9106
strict
0.7851 0.8218 0.8030
relax
0.8533 0.8933 0.8729
- ft
precision recall f1
strict
occurrence 0.5952 0.6214 0.6081
test 0.8323 0.8549 0.8434
problem 0.8469 0.8666 0.8566
treatment 0.8706 0.8504 0.8604
clinical_dept 0.7497 0.8306 0.7881
evidential 0.8263 0.6874 0.7505
relax
occurrence 0.6961 0.7267 0.7110
test 0.9112 0.9360 0.9234
problem 0.9258 0.9473 0.9365
treatment 0.9376 0.9159 0.9266
clinical_dept 0.7916 0.8770 0.8321
evidential 0.8283 0.6891 0.7523
overall
acc: 0.9111
strict
0.7959 0.8059 0.8009
relax
0.8712 0.8822 0.8767
- bitfit 5 epoch
precision recall f1
strict
occurrence 0.6079 0.6291 0.6183
test 0.8544 0.8623 0.8583
problem 0.8662 0.8744 0.8703
treatment 0.8689 0.8766 0.8727
clinical_dept 0.6962 0.8798 0.7773
evidential 0.7849 0.7176 0.7498
relax
occurrence 0.7104 0.7351 0.7225
test 0.9256 0.9341 0.9298
problem 0.9372 0.9462 0.9417
treatment 0.9287 0.9369 0.9328
clinical_dept 0.7384 0.9331 0.8244
evidential 0.7849 0.7176 0.7498
overall
acc: 0.9166
strict
0.8025 0.8213 0.8118
relax
0.8720 0.8925 0.8821
React
Typescript
Django
Laravel
Facebook
Microsoft
Google
Alibaba
D3
Tencent