Alternative cache backends for remote workers about bazel-buildfarm HOT 5 CLOSED

The worker side of this was implemented in #143, we're waiting on an http implementation I threw together in #144 to use as a grpc endpoint for one or many workers, and #153 will enable this on the server

from bazel-buildfarm.

It is not currently possible to separate this right now, but for only the simple reason that we're using the same endpoint for the operation queue, the CAS, and the Action Cache.

Your use case is definitely sound, but I have a thought about providing the support for the different endpoint types in-worker: How about I just make 3 different configurable endpoint addresses for communication over grpc for each of the services, rather than trying to bake in client support for all manner of CAS/AC communication protocols (http, grpc, hazelcast, redis, memcached, mongo, etc).

I can also quite separately (doesn't even have to be in this repo) provide a grpc hosted server that can speak one of these (separate binaries for separate protos) and facilitate proxy/translation for either activity (CAS or AC).

I think it is an effective strategy to combat complexity to say 'the operation queue workers speak grpc and nothing else.'

from bazel-buildfarm.

Hi @werkt, I'm not sure if that was a comment directed at me.

What I was hoping for was to give a flag to the build farm worker to read/write to some cache backend.
I'm not sure how things work so I don't quite understand the 3 different endpoint configurations or the reason for a proxy.

Thanks!

from bazel-buildfarm.

I believe @werkt is saying that currently there are 3 different kinds of things, all handled on a single port by a single binary. If they were (or could be) on different ports, it would be far easier for others to add support for alternate implementation(s) of the functionality - whether it is a shim to use Bazel Remote Cache in place of the internal CAS, a custom AC backend, or what have you.

from bazel-buildfarm.

We've broken things out at this point, have at it!

from bazel-buildfarm.