The QA report checklist for this galaxy

Please complete as you progress through the QA

All data for galaxies can be obtained here

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image

• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map

• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)

• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image

• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)

• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image

• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• #30

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

Annie: OK for science. Baselines OK. CS no clear detection. HCN and HCO+ : flux match OK.

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

Several maps have negative bowls - thoughts on how to address?

#12

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• #33
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• #36
• #37
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy

Please complete as you progress through the QA

Data for galaxies can be obtained here:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1jc1PwXf-U_f_yjCxUl8wrPPE5LzpDzYu/view?usp=sharing

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image

• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map

• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)

• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image

• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)

• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image

• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

Annie: Happy to pass this as science-ready with the caveat that the emission is weak and the uncertainty on the flux measurement is large. There seems to be a slight negative bias for in the baselines for some cubes (perhaps responsible for some of the mismatch in flux between the TP and 7m+TP cubes?) but since the emission is so weak I'm not sure it is worth investing time to improve it.

Some non-standard fits information is included in the header
These have been updated in the _trimmed dataset

• Poor signal to noise throughout - nothing to be done here
• Baseline may be improved - see #6
• Velocity range maybe a little too tight - see #10

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• #35
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• #38
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

Note here - #4 (comment)

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

Annie: OK to set this as science-ready. Baselines look fine. CS is weak. For HCN & HCO+, the flux scaling is OK.

Some additional pixels in mask that could be removed.
Also mask could be dilated to include more emission.

Good example here #18

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

Annie: OK for science. Only non/marginal detections. Some negative bias in the baselines of CS, but since there is no strong emission, not clear that it's worth investing time to improve it.

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• #31
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• #32
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• #34
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• #39

• Dataset science ready?

The QA report checklist for this galaxy
Please complete as you progress through the QA
All data for galaxies can be obtained here

Checklist

• tp - check baseline of single-dish image
• tp - check for artefacts in single-dish image

• 7m - check residual map
• 7m - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)

• 7m+tp - check baseline of 7m image (i.e. in continuum subtraction okay?)
• 7m+tp - check for negative bowls in 7m image
• 7m+tp - check for artefacts in 7m image (linear features in map, large fluxes etc)
• 7m+tp - compare to the single dish image (fluxes okay?)

• Dataset science ready?