`lein with-profile 1.4 test` fails about carmine HOT 6 CLOSED

Tundra is not compatible with clojure 1.4.0

Yes, that's correct. Faraday is 1.5+ so Tundra inherits this dependency. For new libs I'm targeting 1.5+. For older libs (like Carmine) I'm targeting a version behind master (so 1.4 until 1.6 is out).

I was trying to remove expectations as a production dependency, but it seems as though all of your libraries have it as well.

Good catch, thanks - I'll clean that up in future updates. Am curious why you're concerned about the extra dependency though?

from carmine.

I think Carmine fails to compile on 1.4 due to the Faraday dependency, do you see otherwise?

The extra dependency isn't a major concern for my work right now, it's largely just pedantry :). That said, the standard set of reasons apply -- more libraries to vet for security, larger uberjars, etc.

from carmine.

Why was this closed? The issue is still occurring; Carmine is not 1.4 compatible as advertised.

from carmine.

Hi, Carmine is compatible with 1.4 - the tests fail because of the inclusion of the Tundra code which is 1.5+. If you don't specifically pull in the Tundra namespace, you shouldn't have any problem running on 1.4.

Does that help?

from carmine.

Yes, thanks. Do you think it is an issue for development if lein with-profile 1.4 test fails?

Would you be open to splitting the project into a set of libraries? If the Tundra functionality is separate from core functionality and requires a different set of dependencies, I don't think it should be part of the same project. I could say similar things about many of the other features (or anti-features, sometimes).

I really want to get behind all of the work being done here, but every time I want a stripped down Redis client that doesn't surprise me, something happens in Carmine that makes me go berserk.

from carmine.

Do you think it is an issue for development if lein with-profile 1.4 test fails?

You can remove the Farady dependency if you feel better about it, but I would note that it's only in the :test profile.

Would you be open to splitting the project into a set of libraries?

Not at the moment, sorry - I don't think the removal of a test dependency would warrant the effort. You're of course welcome to strip out anything you're not using: the non-core namespaces (like Tundra) are intentionally kept modular.

something happens in Carmine that makes me go berserk.

Not sure how I can help you with that ;-) As I say, you're welcome to strip out anything you find extraneous. I would keep in mind though that I'm planning to drop official 1.4 support a little while after Clojure 1.6 final is out. Migrating from 1.4 to 1.5 is usually quite painless and brings some real benefits.

Hope that helps, cheers! :-)

from carmine.