Faiiled to build what use ndk_context project about dinghy HOT 3 CLOSED

Hi @nziq53 ! We've discussed a bit with @kali about this and concluded that support for JVM applications is not something that seem wise to add inside dinghy, given that tools like cargo apk or xbuild already exist and do exactly that.

Dinghy first goal has always been to be able to test code written for posix like platforms on embedded platforms. In your use case the code you're writing is definitely expecting way more than a posix platform (ie it need to be run inside a process containing an android JVM). One implementation that could be done in dinghy could be to wrap cargo apk or xtools to support these use case, but we fail to see the added value this would bring compared to directly call those specialised tools.

from dinghy.

Hi @nziq53 !

Do you have some code somewhere I can take a look at ?

That being said, it looks like ndk_context needs a quite different approach from what we're doing with dinghy. ndk_context needs an android app VM to initialize whereas dinghy only spawns regular Linux processes on the target device.

Not sure the approach of spawning an app VM it something that is desirable for dinghy. If we do add it it should be behind a flag I guess. But then again we would in that case probably do the same thing that cargo apk / xbuild does.

from dinghy.

@fredszaq
Glad to see a positive response!

Me too. I think must use flag .

my creating repo is https://github.com/nziq53/nickname
my running code on dinghy is: https://github.com/nziq53/nickname/tree/main/examples/common
my running code on cargo-apk: https://github.com/nziq53/nickname/tree/main/examples/android
my test workflow is this: https://github.com/nziq53/nickname/blob/04c30c31a77cb5df3f2e08bd3a4af49c9f4ed39a/.github/workflows/run.yml#L47C17-L47C125
my code on android is: https://github.com/nziq53/nickname/tree/main/rust/android

from dinghy.