join rackt? about reselect HOT 23 CLOSED

Please do. Putting libraries under this org not only gives it credibility, but ensures it's maintained by more than just a single person.

from reselect.

Reselect is such an integral part of Redux ecosystem, that it would be beneficial to host it under rackt for the reasons listed above.

from reselect.

I really don't mind one way or the other, so I will defer to everyone else on this.

But while you are here @faassen, would you mind having a quick look at #50 😉

from reselect.

@ellbee I get undeserved credit for this library right now as it's on my github. It's neat people in the community know my name, and I'm happy and proud I helped create this, but I only am one contributor out of a lot of people, some of whom, including you, did more than I did.

from reselect.

Yeah, I appreciate that and I hope that my comment didn't come across as dismissive of the idea. I just wanted to convey that I am totally comfortable with the situation as it is. I do see that there could be benefits to moving the project.

from reselect.

I think this is a great idea. Given the ecosystem's immaturity, it's tough (at least time-consuming) right now to research and choose React technologies. I'm personally more likely to use a project under the rackt org, and it's nice to save a bit of time on due diligence research (granted, I found reselect through redux docs, so I picked it up with only a skim of the docs).

I agree, as mentioned, that it could also result in more users, more PRs, and lower bus factor.

from reselect.

@ellbee No, you did not come across as dismissive at all. I really appreciate your attitude in this towards me a lot!

I contacted Dan Abramov on Twitter and he was in favor of the idea, and he contacted some of the other Rackt people about it. So now we'll see.

from reselect.

Note that concerning the bus factor, @ellbee has complete access to everything already. Well, I said that until I learned that there was still a travis thing. Not sure how to give access there.

from reselect.

Reasonable. Bus factor isn't quite the right term. I think it's more having a slightly larger pool of folks who can spare cycles for reviewing PRs and attending to issues.

Regarding Travis specifically, I think you need owner privilege because you need the "grant privilege' privilege to allow Travis to create web hooks and use build status API.

from reselect.

This sounds like a great idea, and @gaearon thinks so as well. If you're up for it, our door is open.

from reselect.

Okay, back at email I'll initiate the transfer. I wonder whether ellbee's permissions get transferred. We also need to discuss things like npm and travis permissions, but we'll figure it out as we get along.

from reselect.

Okay I've transferred the organization to rackt.

We need to figure out whether these things work:

• we enabled some travis stuff recently, and I had to give some permissions for this. Does it work under rackt?
• ellbee had full access to the reselect repo, and I don't know whether he still does. He really should as he's been the primary maintainer of the project (and initiated the project along with me). I'm not sure whether I have the access to add him; I don't seem to have access to settings myself.
• does rackt have some kind of policy for who has access to the npm for individual projects?

from reselect.

I invited @ellbee to Redux team in rackt.

from reselect.

Thanks. But I didn't give any teams (such as redux) access to reselect. I don't think I even have access myself now. :)

from reselect.

I do still have commit access. But I don't have access to give people access or give teams access. I'm fine with giving the redux team access to the reselect project though.

from reselect.

Alright, I've joined up! 🎉 And I still have access too, so it's looking good. The travis build badge has broken though.

from reselect.

And fixed.

from reselect.

:D welcome!

from reselect.

Thank you!

from reselect.

So any policy for npm?

from reselect.

And welcome ellbee! Yay!

from reselect.

@faassen @ellbee sorry for beeing away for a litte long. Great work on reselect and it's really great that redux is rackt now.

from reselect.

Done.

from reselect.