Add the ability to have zero amount transaction about android-money-manager-ex HOT 9 CLOSED

I know all of that, I'm using mmex for a lot of years. But if the result of the split transactions is 0, it's impossible to validate because 0 is forbidden. Just do a try and you will see.

from android-money-manager-ex.

Ok. I see your point - a split with a 0 amount is not allowed in MMX Android, but it is allowed in MMX Desktop. So your request is that it should also be allowed in MMX Android so that there is consistency across the two platforms.
I agree. The functionality should be consistent acorss both MMEX and AMMEX.

from android-money-manager-ex.

exactly, @jeepcook.

from android-money-manager-ex.

hi @jeepcook can you explain better your requirement? "null" transaction are available when you create a transaction under Status --> Void

from android-money-manager-ex.

Ok but even if you choose void, you can't validated the transaction because the amount is 0 euro in your screenshot.

Another case is to use split transactions with a negative transaction with an amount and a positive transaction with the same amount, so the total is 0 euro and you can't validate the transaction. An error message say something like "the amount has to be positive..."

Hope I am clear.

from android-money-manager-ex.

What do you want to use null transactions for?

Why would you record a transaction that doesn't have a monetary value in MMX?

And is NULL = 0 in your case?

from android-money-manager-ex.

I want to speak about 0 euro amount, sorry with the confusion with null.
I'd like to have the ability to have the result of transactions in the same operation with the total amount of 0.
Example, when you have a pré-paid opération which is cancelled or refund later. So it's the same operation but with 2 transactions and the result can be positive or 0.
And this can be done with mmex pc so why not whith android version?

from android-money-manager-ex.

Are both the "+" and the "-" transactions always recorded with the same date? If not, isn't it better to use two separate transactions so that you can record the correct dates?

If the dates aren't significant, then why not use a split transaction?
You add two items to the split transaction - one for the "+" event and another for the "-" event. And the nice thing about a split transaction is that you don't have to add both the "+" and "-" events at the same time, assuming they are triggered at different times. You can create the transaction with just the "+" or "-" event and add the other one to the split transactions later.
The only thing you can't do is use different dates for each event.

MMX Android does support split transactions, so this will work on both MMX Desktop and Mobile.

from android-money-manager-ex.

Thanks for this update. Not in the last 2024.02.08.1018 so will be in the 1019 version?

from android-money-manager-ex.