Please pick the version you prefer for Coq 8.18 in Coq Platform 2023.10 about math-comp HOT 13 CLOSED

As discussed I now have two picks:

• an MC 1.18 based one with

coq-mathcomp-ssreflect.1.18.0
coq-mathcomp-fingroup.1.18.0
coq-mathcomp-algebra.1.18.0
coq-mathcomp-solvable.1.18.0
coq-mathcomp-field.1.18.0
coq-mathcomp-character.1.18.0
coq-mathcomp-bigenough.1.0.1
coq-mathcomp-finmap.1.5.2
coq-mathcomp-real-closed.1.1.4
coq-mathcomp-zify.1.3.0+1.12+8.13
coq-mathcomp-multinomials.1.6.0

• an MC2.1 based one with

coq-mathcomp-ssreflect.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-fingroup.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-algebra.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-solvable.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-field.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-character.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-bigenough.1.0.1
coq-mathcomp-finmap.2.0.0
coq-mathcomp-real-closed.2.0.0
coq-mathcomp-zify.1.5.0+2.0+8.16
coq-mathcomp-multinomials.2.1.0

The first one requires quite a few downgrades compared to the second one, which I will discuss in the respective packages.

I am closing this now - please reopen if anything is wrong.

from math-comp.

We still have some time for the release. I am doing the "please pick/tag" issues today and will collect maintainer feedback for all packages which don't work with mathcomp 2.0. In case I don't get feedback in due time, I might ask you for help following up with the maintainers. As soon as we have official feedback, we can discuss what we do.

The tracker issue is linked above - the "please pick" issues should be done by tomorrow.

from math-comp.

Indeed I missed the 2.1 release. If you prefer 2.1, I can try to update.

from math-comp.

And I guess with "all platform packages" you mean all except coq-mathcomp-analysis.

from math-comp.

OK, I go with the above list for Coq Platform 2023.10 then. I will close this issue a bit later today.

from math-comp.

@MSoegtropIMC 2.0 would be nice but there are still currently a few unported things (mostly Analysis, Abel, Jasmin) still relying on 1.17, so don't know what's best (I'd say I'm trusting you here, so if you think 2.0 is fine, let's go for it).

Also note that we plan to release 1.18 and 2.1 by the end of the month.

from math-comp.

Today 2.1 was announced - should we pick this?

It might btw. be that the release will include two picks, one based on 1.18 and one based on 2.0 with everything which works.

from math-comp.

@MSoegtropIMC if possible yes using 2.1.0 would be great (but if this requires too much OPAM packages adaptation, 2.0.0 is fine)

(About mathcomp 1, we plan to release 1.18 next week.)

from math-comp.

@MSoegtropIMC most OPAM packages working with mathcomp 2.0.0 should now work for 2.1.0 (most of the time this was achieved by just bumping the bound in the OPAM file, only multinomials and fourcolor required a new release (resp. 2.1.0 and 1.3.1))

from math-comp.

As discussed in Zulip mathcomp-analysis won't support mathcomp 2.0 before the end of the year, so the conclusion is that the Coq Platform release will include two picks, one based on matchcomp 1.18 and one based on 2.0 (without mathcomp-analysis).

There will be two installers for Mac and Windows. snap does not support this easily, so I would suggest that on snap we use 1.18 for the release and 2.0 for a beta in the 8.18 track.

Is this agreeable? If not, please suggest another solution.

from math-comp.

LGTM, thanks for your efforts!

Note that 2.1 should support all platform packages IINM, but 2.0 is fine too.

from math-comp.

@proux01: I tried this package selection (instead of all 2.0.0) and it also works:

coq-mathcomp-ssreflect.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-fingroup.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-algebra.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-solvable.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-field.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-character.2.1.0
coq-mathcomp-bigenough.1.0.1
coq-mathcomp-finmap.2.0.0
coq-mathcomp-real-closed.2.0.0
coq-mathcomp-zify.1.5.0+2.0+8.16
coq-mathcomp-multinomials.2.1.0

Note that for finmap and real-closed there is no 2.1 as yet.

It is your choice - I can use either version.

from math-comp.

@MSoegtropIMC thanks, sounds good

Note that for finmap and real-closed there is no 2.1 as yet.

Yes, no need for it since their 2.0 version works with mathcomp 2.1

from math-comp.