Suggestion: Filter messages into subfolders about dmarc-srg HOT 12 CLOSED

Hi,
To me, all the email messages in the mailbox that do not content a correct DMARC report are either spam or failed DMARC reports. Spam, ideally, must not reach the mailbox. As for "done", it's easy to implement. As for the "other", I have no idea how to separate them from "failed." The message subject? Its attachment? The number of its attachments? In my opinion only the last one more or less guarantees the correct separation. Do you have any ideas?

from dmarc-srg.

Believe it or not, I'm also a lazy person. But I don't move my email messages. This work is for a sieve script on my server, I only periodically update the rules. I like the unix way - each program should only do one job and do it well. It seems to me that sorting incoming mail messages is not my project's job. However, I promise to consider your suggestion.

from dmarc-srg.

Unsure on easy, but cool for sure :)

Only done and failed. Not dmarc must not be updated.

from dmarc-srg.

done only seems OK, or better : option in config ('moveto' => '') maybe ?

from dmarc-srg.

I'd see processing work like this:

if (processing was successful) move to done
elseif (the message appears to be a DMARC message but there was an error) move to failed
elseif (all the other messages) move to other

Ideally, I view this as a preference.

from dmarc-srg.

@Shnoulle I already thought about a similar option, because I came across a case where the creation of a subfolder in the folder where the dmarc reports are located is prohibited. As an option, either move it to another mailbox (folder), or mark it in some other way. Optionally, of course. It may be IMAP custom keywords if they are allowed on a server, but I'm not sure if php-imap library supports them, I should check it before.

from dmarc-srg.

@mayall The main problem is this phrase: "the message appears to be a DMARC message" :(

from dmarc-srg.

By the way, I'm just curious: what is the difference between messages in the done folder and messages marked as seen and not moved to the failed folder? Just to keep the mailbox clean?

from dmarc-srg.

I move anything with the phrase DMARC into the folder to be processed. I do it that way because I'm lazy. For example, the messages from this thread end up there. Basically, I want anything to do with DMARC to end up in that folder and the subfolders.

I understand that my needs may not be shared by others but it seems like the basic filtering idea would be useful for some and not hurt anything.

from dmarc-srg.

@Shnoulle I already thought about a similar option, because I came across a case where the creation of a subfolder in the folder where the dmarc reports are located is prohibited. As an option, either move it to another mailbox (folder), or mark it in some other way. Optionally, of course. It may be IMAP custom keywords if they are allowed on a server, but I'm not sure if php-imap library supports them, I should check it before.

osticket have some code for this. By default settings is set to INBOX.done

from dmarc-srg.

I've already implemented this feature and even more. Now I'm thinking about what to do with the mailbox cleaner: it's necessary to somehow take into account this variety of settings.

from dmarc-srg.

Done: 5e8614a. Could you check it out?

from dmarc-srg.