Help text shows config option twice about click-extra HOT 5 CLOSED

For the record, the default command and group imported from click_extra is no longer attached with all the defaults options. Nor it is coming with all bells and whistles. In fact command and group are now an alias to Cloup's. So click_extra is now a drop-in replacement without surprises.

If you need all the previous behaviour, use extra_command instead of command and extra_group instead of group.

This huge refactor has been pushed upstream and lots of polishing is still required. It will be part of the upcoming v3.0.0 release.

Nice side effect of the refactoring: it solves the duplicate option and confusing bug you reported initially since all options can now be used standalone too.

from click-extra.

Oh.

In my first iteration of click-extra I wanted all the bells and whistles to be automatically applied out of the box to any group/command structure. To reduce the work done by new users and show them off its advantages. That's why all the options pop-up by default in your examples.

It's only after a while I realized I can speed-up the adoption of click-extra by advertising it as a drop-in replacement for click, but with extras.

Of course the 2 approaches are now conflicting and you're getting confused. I guess the best course of action is to detach all these default options on group and command, and let the user adds them as they see fit.

What do you think?

from click-extra.

While I personally don't mind all the options being enabled by default, my guess is most users will want to enable them manually. Perhaps they're all off by default, but then have an @every_option or @all_options to easily pull in everything.

from click-extra.

And to try to make things easier to grasp, I've written a first draft of a tutorial at: https://kdeldycke.github.io/click-extra/tutorial.html

from click-extra.

This issue has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.

from click-extra.