OutputFormat/Message Tag Lib Issues about mojarra HOT 10 CLOSED

Reported by rogerk

from mojarra.

rogerk said:
OutputMessageRenderer overrides encodeEnd method (from HtmlBasicRenderer) -
so converters are not dealt with.

from mojarra.

rogerk said:
I'll take this one...

from mojarra.

rogerk said:
will enable the usage of converter attribute for outputFormat - converter
should be applied after parameter substitution (if any)..

w/r/t #3 "title" attribute on "message"/"messages" - this will be
deprecated in 1.2. (see issue #20).

from mojarra.

jayashri said:
This issue was filed against jsfaces1.1 release.

from mojarra.

rogerk said:

1. fixed - see issue 23

2. unfortunately, we are stuck with this. converter is a property of anything
   associated with UIOutput (ValueHolder) component. The converter (with UIPutput)
   should only be used when converting from a "value" to string. From a JSF EG member:

While it is weird, I think that all UIOutput renderers
(and all ValueHolders) must use a Converter (if one has
been provided) if they wish to turn the "value" property
of the component into a String. If they don't, they're
breaking the contract of what a UIOutput is.

The issue that this makes relatively little sense for
tags like outputLink and outputFormat means, to my mind,
that we made a mistake in our design, and these renderers
(especially outputLink) should not have been UIOutput
components. UIOutput has been taken to mean "anything
that outputs something", but really should mean "read-only
components that use a Converter with a value".

– Adam

3. we will need to deprecate "title" - see issue 20.

from mojarra.

@manfredriem said:
Closing issue out

from mojarra.

Was assigned to rogerk

from mojarra.

This issue was imported from java.net JIRA JAVASERVERFACES-19

from mojarra.

Marked as won't fix on Wednesday, April 19th 2006, 5:44:32 am

from mojarra.