get-msisummaryinfo : A share violation has occurred about psmsi HOT 6 CLOSED

Note to self: this happens with several cmdlets. Was there some reason why or was it just an oversight?

• Get-MSIFileType
• Edit-MSIPackage (one sharing violation, but then enumerated files in $PWD which is also incorrect)
• Get-MSISummaryInfo

from psmsi.

A path argument is required but doesn't seem like it's enforced for parameter binding. While technically it's a breaking change, since this invocation only errs it should be okay to make a breaking change to require at least one argument.

To see how to use the cmdlets, please run help <cmdlet> or help <cmdlet> -full to see more detailed help including parameters.

from psmsi.

Thanks, I'm used to help being displayed when no arguments are passed. This is traditionally how commands behave. "A share violation has occurred" doesn't explain that an argument is required. It sounds more like a bug in the code.

from psmsi.

PowerShell doesn't work that way, unfortunately. You can pass -? as a sole argument which PowerShell translates to help <cmdlet>, but that's undocumented. Normally, help <cmdlet> or help about_<topic> is what you need to do. You can also run help about to see all available about topics.

So, just to be clear, this cmdlet (or any cmdlet, unless they handle it themselves which would be non-standard) will not display help when no arguments are passed.

Still, I can fix this specific problem since it shouldn't fail that way. It (and all other cmdlets) will prompt for required arguments, though.

from psmsi.

Digging in more, I'm going to leave all but Get-MSISummaryInfo because the others are designed to enumerate all files if no parameters. Not sure why I was getting the sharing violation on one machine, but was unable to reproduce on another.

from psmsi.

PowerShell Gallery has been updated with MSI version 3.3.4 with a fix for this specific issue. If -Path isn't specified, PowerShell will prompt (unless started with -NonInteractive). Bear in mind, however, that cmdlets don't emit help if you don't pass required parameters. Use help <cmdlet> for more information.

Thanks for reporting!

from psmsi.