brdf_scale about nerfactor HOT 5 CLOSED

No. I'm trying to understand how the code works and I've tested the brdf_mlp with some random values obtaining very high values (10 e6). Since albedo is between 0 and 1, the differences between scales are strange andthat's the reason I was curious about the brdf_scale but I think is 1.

Is it the expected mlp_brdf to return so high values?

from nerfactor.

I am having a similar problem. I am doing some modifications to the code and now, I see that the brdf_mlp produces very large values ranging from 1e4 to 1e6 or so. This results on the albedo being not optimized as the final RGB value depends mostly on the specular, which has much higher values than the albedo

from nerfactor.

Hi both, that constant for scaling the BRDF is an artificial scale set empirically. The reason is that the unit of BRDFs is often ambiguous and not physically rigorous. For example, when we pretrained our BRDF MLP on the MERL BRDFs, it was unclear what unit the MERL BRDFs used. Plus, the light probe intensities are not metric either, so somewhere along the rendering pipeline, one would need some scaling, whether at the BRDF output or the final rendering. Feel free to reopen this if you need further help.

from nerfactor.

Hello!
I understand your answer but checking the configuration, brdf_scale seems to be 1 so it would be the same to ignore it. Should it be changed for each scene?
Thanks

from nerfactor.

Hi @SirSykon. Shouldn't need to change that for each scene. Usually, we set one brdf_scale for each BRDF pertaining dataset (e.g., the MERL dataset) because that's what determines the "scale."

from nerfactor.