Platform field for production slides about wuhu HOT 5 CLOSED

I have a conceptual problem with this: one of the basic tenets of Wuhu is that it treats compos (and subsequently entries) as completely agnostic from each other. "Platform" fields would only work if 1. there would be presets for compo types which would go against the above stated goal (i.e. you shouldn't have platforms for a streaming music compo) or 2. would leave it up to the organizers to fill the fields which they would inevitably not do.

If it is a common problem, my solution would be just to expand the text around the submission box on the user side to remind them to add the information to the comment field.

from wuhu.

I agree with 1) completely, the specific use case we were thinking was instances where for instance the 4K and 64K compos get merged, or where a single entry in a different compo gets moved to Wild, for instance. Or just Wild in general, where a lot of esoteric hardware often comes into play. If, say, someone made a 4k procedural graphics entry and it got moved to Wild, then that'd be relevant data for the user to know - that this is indeed a 4k procedural graphics entry, and not a video. Also for oldskool demo competitions this comes into play, as there are often fundamental differences between the different platforms, and having a field for that would make sense (to us).

from wuhu.

That does happen, however I'd argue since the merge usually happens post-deadline when all the entries are in and the organizers have to make the call, it's also up to the organizers to decide if they want to update the slides in such a situation :) (In which case they might as well do it with the comment field.)

from wuhu.

As I see no interest from devs in implementing this, it makes little sense to keep the ticket open.

from wuhu.

I thought there was a good discussion being had...? Also a note: there is nothing stopping a party who needs this to create a plugin without having to touch the main code tree.

from wuhu.