A question about Java and bedrock server protocols about minestat HOT 9 CLOSED

No, it's just that the parameters sometimes named differently between the versions.

• For C#: parameter protocol (https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/blob/master/CSharp/MineStat/MineStat.cs#L160)

  MineStat ms = new MineStat("minecraft.frag.land", 25565, protocol: SlpProtocol.Bedrock_Raknet);

• For Go, its the third optional parameter (and the type for bedrock is REQUEST_BEDROCK) - though I don't know enough about Go to give you an example 😅.

• For Java (as mentioned above by ldilley): parameter requestType (https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/blob/master/Java/me/dilley/MineStat.java#L196)

  MineStat ms = new MineStat("minecraft.frag.land", 25565, MineStat.Request.BEDROCK);

• For Javascript its not possible.

• For PHP: parameter request_type (https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/blob/master/PHP/minestat.php#L79)

  $ms = new MineStat("minecraft.frag.land", 19132, 5, MineStat::REQUEST_BEDROCK);

• For Perl: parameter no. 4 set to REQUEST_BEDROCK

  $ms = Minecraft::ServerStatus::init("minecraft.frag.land", 25565, Minecraft::ServerStatus::REQUEST_BEDROCK);

• For PowerShell: parameter $queryprotocol (https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/blob/master/PowerShell/MineStat/MineStat.psm1#L126)

• For Python: parameter query_protocol (which you can also find in the documentation: https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/tree/master/Python#available-parameters)

  import minestat
  ms = minestat.MineStat('minecraft.frag.land', 25565, query_protocol=minestat.SlpProtocols.BEDROCK_RAKNET)

• For ruby I think you found it yourself (I don't know enough about that language to help you there).

I hope this has cleared up your question 😃!

from minestat.

Dear @molanp, welcome to MineStat :)

In most of the language variants of minestat you can already choose the protocol to use for communication with the Minecraft server. Since Bedrock/MCPE only uses only one specific network protocol, you can simply set that.

How exactly that works depends on which variant of MineStat you are using.
For example in Python you can use the parameter query_protocol, in the Java variant requestType and similar in other variants.

For explicitly saying "only Java server" there isn't currently any way that I can think of. If you need that/would like to have that, we can track that as a new feature request.

Best regards,
MindSolve

from minestat.

Bedrock servers are not always BEDROCK_RAKNET query_protocol, and it may be EXTENDED_LEGACY (e.g. 2b2t.xin) or something else, and the query_protocol of Java servers is not always JSON, and it seems impossible to identify the server type through a limited number of protocols

from minestat.

Oh.Is the slp_protocol obtained by the query the same as the query_protocol in the request parameters, and the above are slp_protocol results

from minestat.

Is there a specific language for which you are observing this behavior, @molanp? I just successfully tested Geyser (listening on TCP 25565 and UDP 25565) using the Java implementation of MineStat. In this case, the default behavior checks for TCP communication first if port 19132 is not specified. If you want the Bedrock server results, simply specify Bedrock as the protocol to use. See examples below.

TCP (legacy, beta, extended, and JSON SLP) is attempted first:

MineStat ms = new MineStat("minecraft.frag.land");

UDP (Bedrock) is used explicitly even while using the default non-Bedrock server port:

MineStat ms = new MineStat("minecraft.frag.land", 25565, MineStat.Request.BEDROCK);

from minestat.

I only see this parameter in Ruby and PHP, it seems that only these two languages are supported?

from minestat.

oh.THANKS!i found it.

from minestat.

No, it's just that the parameters sometimes named differently between the versions.

• For C#: parameter protocol (https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/blob/master/CSharp/MineStat/MineStat.cs#L160)

  MineStat ms = new MineStat("minecraft.frag.land", 25565, protocol: SlpProtocol.Bedrock_Raknet);

• For Go, its the third optional parameter (and the type for bedrock is REQUEST_BEDROCK) - though I don't know enough about Go to give you an example 😅.
• For Java (as mentioned above by ldilley): parameter requestType (https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/blob/master/Java/me/dilley/MineStat.java#L196)

  MineStat ms = new MineStat("minecraft.frag.land", 25565, MineStat.Request.BEDROCK);

• For Javascript its not possible.
• For PHP: parameter request_type (https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/blob/master/PHP/minestat.php#L79)

  $ms = new MineStat("minecraft.frag.land", 19132, 5, MineStat::REQUEST_BEDROCK);
  

• For Perl: parameter no. 4 set to REQUEST_BEDROCK

  $ms = Minecraft::ServerStatus::init("minecraft.frag.land", 25565, Minecraft::ServerStatus::REQUEST_BEDROCK);

• For PowerShell: parameter $queryprotocol (https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/blob/master/PowerShell/MineStat/MineStat.psm1#L126)
• For Python: parameter query_protocol (which you can also find in the documentation: https://github.com/FragLand/minestat/tree/master/Python#available-parameters)

  import minestat
  ms = minestat.MineStat('minecraft.frag.land', 25565, query_protocol=minestat.SlpProtocols.BEDROCK_RAKNET)

• For ruby I think you found it yourself (I don't know enough about that language to help you there).

I hope this has cleared up your question 😃!

It seems that the README.md did not write what options the protocol parameters have

from minestat.

Yeah, that's correct. We are still working on the documentation. Until that's finished, we only have the minimal working example documented (in the readme & most of the time with a example file). For Python it's already documented.

from minestat.