Show side view in bill's text only when a change is detected. about bill-tracker HOT 8 CLOSED

This will not be implemented.

from bill-tracker.

Why not? I mean, wasn't this what we discussed and is available in #29?

from bill-tracker.

Take in mind, this design + add and remove combined looks like this:

The idea is don't add the concept of change and show the text as #29

from bill-tracker.

But we agreed that add and remove wouldn't show the side-by side interface, whereas change would.

I don't understand what you're implying.

from bill-tracker.

and what happen when you have add remove and change combined in the same section?
The last image, show this situation.

from bill-tracker.

I see your point. I'd say:

If change is present in the same paragraph as where either an add or a remove is present (or both, or multiple) then it makes sense to show a side-view element with all changes. If no change is present, then we could leave it as a simple add/remove.

So, basically change > (add || remove) in terms of what to display.

from bill-tracker.

That was the initial approach of #31 and #29 I leave it, because:

• it's going to take more time introduce the concept of difference.
• Is confusing in the scenario I describe it before.
• it's going to take more time introduce the 2 actions of the same button.

To avoid start a infinite discussion because we can't be agree what is the best approach. Lets go with the #29 first, and then do a A/B test with the 2 approaches with #31

from bill-tracker.

Agree

from bill-tracker.