Printing messages without newlines or separators about expound HOT 4 CLOSED

@vemv I haven't dug in, but off the top of my head, I think it'd require some pretty in-depth design on a number of parts of error messages, including

1. How to highlight the bad value when it's part of a larger value
2. How to handle multiple branches of or specs
3. How to print out tables of missing keys

Just fair warning - you're welcome to make a PR, but I think the bar for this change is pretty high and I'll probably politely decline the PR unless it works across the range of features that Expound includes 😄 .

from expound.

@vemv Hi, thanks very much for your question!

There is not currently an option to remove the newlines and separators. The error messages in Expound rely on whitespace (including newlines) in a number of cases. For instance, in the following example, the error message relies on newlines to underline the bad part of the map:

;; -- Spec failed --------------------

;;   {:city ..., :state :CO}
;;                      ^^^

;; should satisfy

;;   string?

I can certainly understand why messages without newlines would be useful in your context, but Expound's error messages are intentionally multi-line and verbose to assist with understanding.

A different set of messages that are single-line and compact would be also useful, but out of scope for this particular project.

Thanks!

from expound.

Thanks for the explanation @bhb !

I might give a shot to a PR, assuming the changes aren't too intrusive.

from expound.

Again, thanks for the fair warning!

I gave some thought to your feedback.

Probably plain data could do the job:

{:bad-value "X"
 :bad-value-path [0 0 :foo 0] ;; get-in style
 :missing-keys [:x :y :z]
 :branches [...]
 ...
}

Something like that. With a bit of luck, expound could build this data structure first, and present its traditional informational messages on top of that.

It doesn't sound easy but I had been wanting to allocate a day to FOSS!

from expound.