Revise watch rating system about asteroidos.org HOT 4 OPEN

My proposal:
First star is awarded for a watch that is in 'proof of concept' state:

• boots
• must have working gui and touch, launcher is navigable

Second star: any of:

• bluetooth
• fully working suspend, including adequate battery life
• if disassembly/dock required, assembly process/dock is adequately documented and 3d printing files are made available

Third star: all of:

• bluetooth
• fully working suspend, including adequate battery life
• if disassembly/dock required, assembly process/dock is adequately documented and 3d printing files are made available

Fourth star:

• working WiFi
• most sensors present on the watch which are suppported by asteroidos are working (device-specific weird sensors and peripherals are not required)
• always on display, or equivalent, works
• minor UI stutters are allowed
• disassembly/building a dock is not required for flashing
• there are no serious hardware issues (such as koi)

Fifth star:

• Mostly subjective
• influenced by good battery life, UI fluidity, presence of GPS
• AsteroidOS Recommends!

from asteroidos.org.

I'd also add the categories for these ratings to the wiki so that users have a better understanding of what we assess

from asteroidos.org.

Having skimmed through all watches and calculating the star rating according to the new proposed rating rules, i have no obligation against these changes and welcome the added clarity and traceability.

Many users showed slight confusion over the current rating system, especially about the fact that rather old watches with few hardware features have a better rating than newer and available ones.
Excluding watches that lack GPS from 5 stars is a good way to highlight catfish and beluga as our currently recommended go to acquisitions.
Making bluetooth clearly a requirement for the 3 stars daily driver level is only pushing pike back to 2 stars for now. But clearly makes a cut for future ports to be able to sync with a phone to be a serious daily driver. Which i welcome for clarity.

from asteroidos.org.

Makes sense to me too yes :) Thanks!

from asteroidos.org.