Requests with endpoint="/_api/simple/..." fail about python-arango HOT 10 CLOSED

It looks like the request has reached some server.
Are you behind a proxy or something? I just don't get it, why does it say "method not supported", when it is clearly a POST request that should work fine 🤨
Are you the one managing arango.myHost.com? If yes, you're running a cluster, or a is it a single server setup?
I am finding it a bit weird that there's not port number. In a cluster setup, the requests should reach one of the coordinator servers (usually port 8529 or 8530). Have you set up any ports? If you send a request to an HTTP URL without specifying the port, the default port for the HTTP protocol is 80.

from python-arango.

Hello @dpro-shc,

Based on the error you provided, I have a few observations and questions:

• [ERR 17] indicates a type error, typically related to the collection name. However, I'm curious to know if the error message you posted is complete. It cuts off after "expecting string for". If there's more to it, that could provide additional clues.
• Are you able to run other operations successfully on that collection? For example, inserting a document.
• Could you confirm if you're running ArangoDB as a cluster or a single server? I'm making an assumption here that you're using the community edition.
• For troubleshooting, it would be beneficial to understand the structure of the creds argument you're passing. While I don't need the actual values (for security reasons), could you provide the kwarg keys that you're using?

I tried replicating the error on my end, but everything seems to work as expected. I'll post a working example below for your reference. Perhaps you can compare it with your code to see if there are any differences.

from arango import ArangoClient
client = ArangoClient(hosts="http://127.0.0.1:8529")
db = client.db('_system', username='root', password='passwd', verify=True)
if db.has_collection('raw_streams'):
  raw_streams = db.collection('raw_streams')
else:
  raw_streams = db.create_collection('raw_streams')
raw_streams.insert({"foo": "bar"})
print(list(raw_streams.all()))

from python-arango.

Hi @apetenchea,

• Sorry about that, I thought the whole error was posted. The rest of the error: "DocumentGetError: [HTTP 400][ERR 17] expecting string for "
• raw_streams.has({'_key':'bar'}) works fine, raw_streams.get({'_key':'bar'}), raw_streams.properties() and raw_streams.name also work as expected.
• Inserting does not and gives the same error as posted, with the following:
  • "DocumentInsertError: [HTTP 404][ERR 1203] expecting GET /_api/document//"
  • I have the feeling all methods that don't contain requests to "/_api/simple" work as expected and those that do throw their respective errors
• Your assumption is correct, I'm running the CE.
• The creds dict looks like: creds = {'name':'myDB','username':'root','password':'passwd'}

My code matches your example and throws the insert error. I'm not connecting to a localhost, maybe that could be part of the problem?

from python-arango.

Document insertion uses _api/document. I would've expected the error to show something like _api/document/raw_streams/, but it does not. I suspect the collection name is not passed correctly in the request.
Could you try to bypass the driver, and see what a POST request returns? The driver itself does more or less the same, it just composes the request and sends it over to the coordinator. See the example in the documentation on how to insert a document using curl.
For the sake of simplicity, please try it out using a database that does not use credentials nor JWT.

If you want to see exactly how the request sent by your driver looks like, you may add the following patch to arango/connection.py:

diff --git a/arango/connection.py b/arango/connection.py
index 49aa7b6..195a9eb 100644
--- a/arango/connection.py
+++ b/arango/connection.py
@@ -128,6 +128,7 @@ class BaseConnection:
         tries = 0
         indexes_to_filter: Set[int] = set()
         while tries < self._host_resolver.max_tries:
+            print(self._url_prefixes[host_index] + request.endpoint)
             try:
                 resp = self._http.send_request(
                     session=self._sessions[host_index],

To get the location of your package run pip show python-arango. Don't forget to undo this change once you're done experimenting.

from python-arango.

I just tried out bypassing the driver in a few ways:

locally on my computer through swaggerHub, which worked flawlessly and through an app running on a separate container, which didn't work.

The POST that failed yielded:
"status":"rejected", "reason":{ "message":"404 - "{\"code\":404,\"error\":true,\"errorMessage\":\"expecting GET /_api/document/<collection>/<key>\",\"errorNum\":1203}"", "name":"Error",

using { headers: {…}, method: "POST", uri: "http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDB/_api/document/raw_streams"

I tried a GET on the collection it was successful on the container, returning the expected collection properties from the url: http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDB/_api/collection/raw_streams

With the added code in the driver, the insert printed: http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDB/_api/document/raw_streams, which exactly what I used for testing in swaggerHub and worked successfully.

For raw_streams.all() I got: http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDB/_api/simple/all

from python-arango.

With the added code in the driver, the insert printed: http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDB/_api/document/raw_streams, which exactly what I used for testing in swaggerHub and worked successfully.

The insert worked successfully from the python driver, or just from swaggerHub?

I changed the print statement in the driver code to print slightly more details from the request:

print(self._url_prefixes[host_index] + request.endpoint, request.data, request.method, request.params, request.headers)

The code I am using to test it is this:

from arango import ArangoClient
client = ArangoClient(hosts="http://127.0.0.1:8529")
db = client.db('_system', username='root', password='passwd', verify=True)
db.delete_collection('raw_streams')
if db.has_collection('raw_streams'):
  raw_streams = db.collection('raw_streams')
else:
  raw_streams = db.create_collection('raw_streams')
raw_streams.insert({"foo": "bar"})
print(list(raw_streams.all()))

I am getting the following output:

http://127.0.0.1:8529/_db/_system/_api/collection None get {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.8 ()'}
http://127.0.0.1:8529/_db/_system/_api/collection/raw_streams None delete {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.8 ()'}
http://127.0.0.1:8529/_db/_system/_api/collection None get {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.8 ()'}
http://127.0.0.1:8529/_db/_system/_api/collection {'name': 'raw_streams', 'waitForSync': False, 'isSystem': False, 'keyOptions': {'type': 'traditional', 'allowUserKeys': True}, 'type': 2} post {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.8 ()'}
http://127.0.0.1:8529/_db/_system/_api/document/raw_streams {'foo': 'bar'} post {'returnNew': '0', 'silent': '0', 'overwrite': '0', 'returnOld': '0'} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.8 ()'}
http://127.0.0.1:8529/_db/_system/_api/simple/all {'collection': 'raw_streams'} put {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.8 ()'}
[{'_key': '6024109', '_id': 'raw_streams/6024109', '_rev': '_gdnjSDW---', 'foo': 'bar'}]

Does it look similar if you try it?

from python-arango.

The insert did not work on the python driver, but it did on swagger. Also I tried using pyArango, which has been working flawlessly.

• Output of raw_streams = db.collection('raw_streams') raw_streams.all()

http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDb/_api/simple/all {'collection': 'raw_streams'} put {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.3 ()'}

• Output of raw_streams.insert({"_key":"foo"})

http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDb/_api/document/raw_streams {'_key': 'foo'} post {'returnNew': '0', 'silent': '0', 'overwrite': '0', 'returnOld': '0'} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.3 ()'}

• Creating a collection doesn't return any errors, but the added collection does not truly make its way into arango

db.create_collection("test2") returns WARNING:urllib3.connectionpool:Retrying (Retry(total=2, connect=None, read=None, redirect=None, status=None)) after connection broken by 'RemoteDisconnected('Remote end closed connection without response')': /_db/dwh/_api/collection http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDb/_api/collection {'name': 'test2', 'waitForSync': False, 'isSystem': False, 'keyOptions': {'type': 'traditional', 'allowUserKeys': True}, 'type': 2} post {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.3 ()'} http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDb/_api/collection {'name': 'test2', 'waitForSync': False, 'isSystem': False, 'keyOptions': {'type': 'traditional', 'allowUserKeys': True}, 'type': 2} post {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.3 ()'}

I think this may not be an issue with the python-arango and might be something I've got wrong in the DB config. Sorry for the confusion. Do you have any ideas?

from python-arango.

The requests seem to be fine. I can suggest updating the driver, although that shouldn't make much of a difference.
The warning generated by urllib3 looks like an indication of connection issues.
Regarding raw_streams.all() or other calls that go through /_api/simple/, note that /api/simple/ is deprecated since ArangoDB 3.4. It should still work though, but it's something we plan on replacing throughout the driver anyway. In the meantime, you can achieve the same using an AQL query:

print(list(db.aql.execute('FOR doc IN raw_streams RETURN doc')))

from python-arango.

Unfortunately db.aql.execute("FOR doc IN raw_sources RETURN doc") prints this:
http://arango.myHost.com/_db/myDB/_api/cursor {'query': 'FOR doc IN raw_sources RETURN doc', 'count': False, 'memoryLimit': 0} post {} {'charset': 'utf-8', 'content-type': 'application/json', 'x-arango-driver': 'python-arango/7.5.3 ()'}

and raises the error:
AQLQueryExecuteError: [HTTP 405][ERR 405] method not supported

If it is a connection error, would you have any idea what it might be?

from python-arango.

my gosh, you're right. Sending requests to https fixed the problems 🤦
Thank you for the help and sorry for the confusion!

from python-arango.