Cannot detect ledger on MacOS Ventura 13.6 or MacOs Sonoma about ledger-cosmos-go HOT 13 CLOSED

Seems related
cosmos/gaia#2756

from ledger-cosmos-go.

I'm getting:

Error: failed to generate ledger key: failed to retrieve device: ledger nano S: no ledger connected

On both Ventura 13.6 and Sonoma 14.0.

Sonoma prompted me if I wanted to allow the Ledger device to connect at the OS level and I explicitly said yes. Perhaps the binary needs to be given explicit permission to use USB now?

from ledger-cosmos-go.

I'm in the same situation.

from ledger-cosmos-go.

I sounds to me that this is related to this https://support.apple.com/en-us/102282 as Tony was suggesting.
We will investigate

from ledger-cosmos-go.

@jleni curiously I can confirm what @zmanian said where older binaries seem to work

from ledger-cosmos-go.

I'm gettin a slightly different error but on the second time that I ran the command it worked fine.

macOS Sonoma 14.0
Ledger NanoS+
Ledger Cosmos app: v2.34.12 

> gaiad version
v13.0.0
> gaiad keys add ledger1 --ledger

Error: failed to generate ledger key: failed to recover pubkey: hidapi: unknown failure: address rejected for path m/44'/118'/0'/0/0
Usage:
  gaiad keys add <name> [flags]

I just ran the command again and I was able to create the key.

PS:
I was able to reproduce the first error: please, check that you closed LedgerLive or any other app that might be using usb port

> gaiad keys add ledger1 --ledger
override the existing name ledger1 [y/N]: y
Error: failed to generate ledger key: failed to retrieve device: ledger nano S: hidapi: failed to open device

from ledger-cosmos-go.

@ftheirs that seems like a different problem.

I can confirm I have repeatedly tried this and get the exact same error every time.

That includes repeatedly plugging in and unplugging the Ledger, across two different computers, both of which exhibit the same error "ledger nano S: no ledger connected"

from ledger-cosmos-go.

Hey @zmanian, @tony-iqlusion, @jjangg96: there is a new release from ledger-cosmos-go. Can you check if it works on your end? The issue is related to some legacy code for mac os 10.5 and earlier versions.

from ledger-cosmos-go.

Any suggestions where best to try it out?

I tried to use it on Agoric which is our most pressing issue here, however that's currently using v0.11 of ledger-cosmos-go and v0.13 is not a drop-in replacement:

# github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/crypto/ledger
../../../../../go/pkg/mod/github.com/agoric-labs/[email protected]/crypto/ledger/ledger_real.go:18:10: cannot use device (variable of type *ledger_cosmos_go.LedgerCosmos) as SECP256K1 value in return statement: *ledger_cosmos_go.LedgerCosmos does not implement SECP256K1 (wrong type for method SignSECP256K1)
		have SignSECP256K1([]uint32, []byte, byte) ([]byte, error)
		want SignSECP256K1([]uint32, []byte) ([]byte, error)

from ledger-cosmos-go.

hey @tony-iqlusion, have you checked this release? There is another team that didn't want to upgrade to v0.13.x because of the breaking changes from Textual mode.

from ledger-cosmos-go.

Okay, that compiled, and I'm getting a slightly different error (the same one @zmanian was getting):

Error: failed to generate ledger key: failed to retrieve device: ledger nano S: hidapi: failed to open device

from ledger-cosmos-go.

FYI, I was able to get agd to work again using this patch to Agoric from @zmanian: Agoric/agoric-sdk#8462

It bumps hid to v0.9.2

from ledger-cosmos-go.

Yeap, the issue is related to hid module but it's a dependency from ledger-go and ledger-cosmos-go. Great to hear that it's working on your end too 🎉

from ledger-cosmos-go.